Skip to content

Is Brock Purdy Overrated

Brock Purdy, born on December 27, 1999, is an American football quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Iowa State Cyclones and was selected by the 49ers with the final pick in the 2022 NFL draft. Despite starting his rookie season as the third-string quarterback, Purdy took over the starting role following injuries to Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo. His performance has been a topic of debate among fans and analysts alike.

The Overrated Status of Brock Purdy

Brock Purdy has been a subject of debate regarding his status in the NFL. Some hail him as a gem and potential franchise player, while others question whether he is overrated.

Purdy had a successful college career at Iowa State, breaking multiple records and earning numerous accolades. Despite his impressive college statistics, his draft stock fell due to middling results in college, leading to his selection in the seventh round of the 2022 draft as the final pick by the San Francisco 49ers. Since taking over as the 49ers’ starting quarterback, Purdy has thrown 4,280 passing yards, 31 touchdown passes, and has a 69.4% completion percentage. His leadership qualities are also attributed to his impressive performance and statistics which led to many meaningful victories.

However, critics question his arm strength and the ability to consistently make deep throws. They also argue that his success is primarily due to Shanahan’s coaching style and strategy. Furthermore, Purdy’s breakout season is his first as a full-time starter, raising questions about sustainability and lack of experience. Brock is yet to prove himself in the postseason, where pressure intensifies and he hasn’t been able to successfully get a decisive win over other better teams and stronger competition.

Despite these criticisms, many believe that Purdy is not overrated. ESPN NFL Analyst Louis Riddick, for instance, firmly believes in Purdy’s abilities. He argues that people who try to cut him down are ignoring the fact that the stats say he’s one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. Riddick also points out that people don’t look at Purdy in the same way they do a Patrick Mahomes or a C.J. Stroud based on the eye test. But by all objective measures, Purdy is playing the position the way it is intended to be played.

Defense of Brock Purdy

Louis Riddick, an ESPN NFL Analyst, has been a vocal defender of Brock Purdy, the quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers. Riddick has taken a strong stance against critics who view Purdy as merely a game manager.

Riddick’s defense of Purdy is rooted in his belief in Purdy’s abilities and performance. He argues that people who try to cut him down are ignoring the fact that the stats say he’s one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. If Purdy wins the Super Bowl, Riddick anticipates that critics will twist themselves into a pretzel trying to discredit what he did.

Riddick also calls out the hypocrisy in judging Purdy. He points out that people don’t look at Purdy in the same way they do a Patrick Mahomes or a C.J. Stroud based on the eye test. But by all objective measures, Purdy is playing the position the way it is intended to be played.

In response to the label of Purdy as a game manager, Riddick argues that this view is used as a way to diminish his accomplishments. He believes in what Purdy is doing and sees his operation of Kyle Shanahan’s offense as a testament to his skill and not a limitation.

Brock Purdy’s Response to the Controversy

Brock Purdy has been at the center of a debate regarding his performance and status in the NFL. Despite the controversy, Purdy maintains a composed and positive outlook.

When asked about how he feels about being a lightning rod for debate, Purdy responded with a smirk, “It’s all good. That’s the sport. That’s the nature of it. You’re in the NFL. Everybody is going to be watching you. You’re in the spotlight. Some people are going to want to see you have success and some people are going to want to see your downfall – that’s just the nature of it. Honestly, it makes it entertaining and fun. Do I get wrapped up in it? No, but obviously I hear things every so often and after all this is said and done, it will be fun for everybody to look back at.”

Purdy’s perspective on the debate is one of indifference. He believes that the arguments about his performance are irrelevant at the moment. What matters to him is that the 49ers can win with him as their quarterback. He acknowledges that he has made mistakes and has not played his best football during the 49ers’ current playoff run. However, he also points out that he has stepped up when needed and has done enough to lead the 49ers back to the Super Bowl.

In terms of handling the criticism, Purdy does not let it affect him. He tries to tune it out and focuses on his performance on the field. He views the criticism as part of the sport and finds it entertaining. He also appreciates that everyone has something to say about him, stating, “Yeah, sometimes, it’s part of it. It’s pretty fun.”

Public Opinion on Brock Purdy

Public opinion on Brock Purdy, the quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers, varies widely, with viewpoints ranging from criticism to support.

On one hand, Purdy has faced significant criticism. Some critics, including notable analysts, have labeled him as a mere “game manager”. They argue that Purdy’s success is primarily due to the 49ers’ system and the skill positions around him. Critics also point out that Purdy doesn’t raise the level of play of anyone around him. This criticism is particularly prevalent at the national level.

However, Purdy also has a strong base of support. Many of his teammates, including Deebo Samuel, Arik Armstead, and Brandon Aiyuk, have come to his defense. They argue that Purdy has led the league in almost every category and that the criticism he faces is unwarranted. Media members such as Pat McAfee, Richard Sherman, Emmanuel Acho, Greg Olsen, and others have also defended Purdy.

In online forums, the debate around Purdy is ongoing. Some users argue that Purdy is a product of the system, while others defend his abilities and performance. Some users point out that Purdy has demonstrated a diverse arsenal, especially with major implications on the line.

Brock Purdy’s Performance

Purdy has demonstrated exceptional skill, ranking first in passer rating (116.9), yards per attempt (9.9), and completion rate (70.2%) for the 2023 season. However, his performance against the Green Bay Packers in the Divisional Round raised questions regarding his consistency, as he struggled significantly in that matchup1. Rain appeared to negatively affect Purdy’s performance, causing him to miss basic throws and struggle with accuracy. Contrastingly, Purdy performed exceptionally well in the Super Bowl LVIII, finishing with 255 passing yards, one touchdown, and no turnovers. Despite occasional struggles, Purdy’s overall body of work suggests potential for continued development and success in the league. Criticism of Purdy often focuses on specific instances, whereas supporters highlight his achievements and potential for growth. Ultimately, Purdy’s performance warrants discussion regarding whether his strengths justify the praise or the criticism he receives.


The impact of public opinion on athletes’ careers is significant. For Brock Purdy, the debate around his status as an overrated or underrated player has been a prominent part of his journey as a quarterback in the NFL. Regardless of the controversy, Purdy’s performance on the field speaks for itself. His journey from being the last pick in the 2022 NFL draft to becoming a key player for the San Francisco 49ers is a testament to his skill, determination, and resilience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *